From ryardumian at ciis.canon.com  Wed Aug  9 00:56:33 2017
From: ryardumian at ciis.canon.com (ryardumian at ciis.canon.com)
Date: Wed,  9 Aug 2017 00:56:33 +0000 (UTC)
Subject: [WIMS] [PWG5107.3] Issue #63: Please resolve MFD Alert issues and
	register them with IANA
Message-ID: <issue-63@www.pwg.org>

[Issue Unconfirmed]

Canon is stating that in specification ???5107.3-2012 ??? Printer MIB and
IPP MFD Alerts(MFD Alerts)???,
- page 17, MFD and Print Extension Subunit Alerts has these values
  - SubunitAlert: PrtAlertCodeTC
        scannerLightMissing :5104
        scannerSensorLifeAlmostOver : 5111
        scannerSensorLifeOver : 5112
        scannerSensorFailure : 5113
        scannerSensorMissing : 5114
  but page 18, section 5.3 IPP printer-status-reasons has
   -  PrtAlertCodeTC : IPP printer-state-reasons
        scannerSensorLifeAlmostOver(5104) : scanner-sensor-life-almost-over
        scannerSensorLifeOver(5105) : scanner-sensor-life-over
        scannerSensorFailure(5106) : scanner-sensor-failure

so there are conflicting values between these two pages as well as page 18
missing the scannerLightMissing and scannerSensorMissing. I'm assuming the
values should be the same between the groups but I could be wrong about
this.

Also in section 9.2 Alert Codes, Scanner Group
   scannerLightMissing and scannerSensorMissing are not in the Scanner
Group list. Should they be in the list?

Please resolve the above issues and do the IANA registration.

Link: http://www.pwg.org/issues/63